The 5 Best Goat Milk Soaps

It that seem an alchemical challenge when it comes to finding the best goat-milk soaps with pure, natural ingredients. There’s a lot to know about processes and ingredients for soap making in order to select the best soap for your skin, function and price point.

Goat milk soap should be plain, beyond nourishing oils such as coconut, palm, and olive oil as well as essential oils for fragrance or health benefits. GMO products such as soybean, corn, canola, potato, or modified rapeseed oil are ingredients to flag — although the FDA has found no proof that GMOs are less safe, the rule of thumb for soap is simplicity.

You’ll also want to avoid sodium lauryl sulfate, which is an emulsifier that improves soap lather, which strips the skin of healthy oils that occur naturally. Nevertheless, sodium hydroxide, or lye, is fine — it is added early in the soap making cycle, and is typically not present in the finished product, although sometimes identified as an ingredient.

Here’s a list of the best goat milk soaps to make adding goat milk soap as easy as the soap should be to your routine.

Horse O Peace Ranch Oatmeal ‘n Honey Goat Milk Soap

Horse ‘O Peace Ranch’s goat milk soap is made from 100 percent raw goat milk and without water (a soap drying agent) by hand poured and cut in the United States. Chemical fragrance-free, dye-free and filler-free, Horse’O Peace Ranch goat milk soap has a pH level of 7 and is a perfect, inexpensive start on the goat milk soap market ($1.20 an ounce).

Contains other naturally nourishing ingredients such as organic oatmeal, which purifies skin, battles acne, and hydrates dry, itchy skin along with organic honey, this soap is the best all-around, unscented goat milk soap. Olive oil, raw goat milk, coconut oil, organic palm oil, sodium hydroxide (lye), and vitamin E are basic ingredients.

Yellow Bird Lavender and Oatmeal Goat Milk Soap

Though a little more expensive than the other goat milk soaps from this list (at $2.20 an ounce), this goat milk soap has over 1,000 reviews on Amazon and a 4.5-star rating. Yellow Bird is a cruelty free (although not Leaping Bunny Certified), family-owned company and its products are all handmade in the United States with GMO-free, paraben-free, soy-free, sulfate-free, gluten-free, natural ingredients (many of which are organic), and you can feel good about this goat’s milk soap (the money-back guarantee doesn’t hurt either).

Yellow Bird uses the cold process approach to produce its soaps without harsh chemicals, dyes or synthetic fragrances in small batches.

Legend’s Creek Unscented Goat Milk Soap

The unscented goat milk soap of Legend Creek is made from their own farm-raised goats with milk, and from their hives raw honey. This goat milk soap is just as farm to shower as it comes and its list of ingredients is as uncomplicated as it is: goat milk, olive saponified oils, coconut, hemp, shea, lye and oatmeal. This fragrance-free goat milk soap is suitable for those with sensitive skin without phosphates, sulfates, parabens, or dyes. In addition, the soap is biodegradable and certified Cruelty Free by Leaping Bunny (the only soap certified by Leaping Bunny on this list).

Our Earth’s Secrets Melt and Pour Goat Milk Soap

The goat milk soap base of our Earth’s Secrets is ideal for those who want to play with tailoring their own goat milk soaps — just melt and pour into molds or apply essential oils to scented soaps.

Our Earth’s Secrets work directly with growers and manufacturers to be environmentally aware and use organic ingredients. While this drug has just 10 percent of goat’s milk, this soap is still soybean-free and manufactured in the USA. The goat milk soap base is a great start for the DIY soap maker for a bit of creative independence.

Southern Natural Rosemary Mint Goat’s Milk Soap

This gift package for Southern Natural Goat Milk Soap comes with two 4-ounce bars and a soap socket to make soap last longer, making this a perfect gift package for any occasion.

The goat milk soap from Southern Natural is made the “good old-fashioned” way: with no animal fats, just high-quality, food-grade vegetable oils and butters. This soap is literally fresh goat’s milk, essential oils, and fragrance oils, mixed using the method of cold processing. Saponified oils of olive, coconut, palm oil, goat milk, distilled water, and essential oils of rosemary and spearmint are included in the ingredient list for this particular soap.